The Illusion Of Successful Investing

I was appointed the finance correspondent for Senior Life Advisor, an online magazine for investors near or in retirement. The articles for Senior Life Advisor were designed to offer actionable information as well as items of interest about economics, investing and personal finance.

The chart below, which shows the price performance of Google shares since the company went public likely provokes a familiar reaction:  Wow, I wish I got in early.  Since going public in 2004, Google shares have gone from $85 to about $1,325 for a gain of 1,458%.  

But the chart also offers two lessons about what it takes to be a successful stock market investors:  patience and conviction.  

Patience: The left endpoint of of the red line shows the price of Google shares in October of 2007 was $354, while the right endpoint shows that in September of 2012 the price of Google shares was . . . $354.  That means investors saw no price appreciation for five years.  Five years was more than half the time Google was a public company.  Five years is 12% of your working years to save for retirement.  To earn the 1,458% return Google has offered since going public, investors had to be very, very patient.  

Conviction:   Between July of 2018 and December of 2018 Google shares fell from $1,238 to $979, as shown by the orange line, for a total decline of 21%.  A 21% loss of value five months is a stunning challenge to any investor’s conviction.  A worse decline , shown by the brown line occurred between October of 2007 and November 2008, when shares went from $354 to $130 for an astonishing loss of 63% percent of its value.  

Stock performance charts are deceptive.  The eye tends to look at the differential between the left endpoint and the right endpoint.  Further, arithmetically, what are likely larger numbers on the right hand side, tend to make the declines in earlier years look smaller simply because those numbers are smaller.  But when looked at carefully, charts tell a tale of patience and conviction among investors who stayed in for the long haul.


Google IPO Price

More Posts

Financial Institutions Feeling the Crunch in Countdown to CECL Implementation

I was retained by Big Four accounting and consulting firm KPMG to assist them in their thought leadership efforts centered on changing accounting regulations. In this case, the Financial Accounting Standards Board or FASB had instituted new rules on the measurement of current and expected credit losses, i.e. CECL, that would require massive reorganization of financial reporting for the largest financial services organizations in the world. This thought leadership piece concerned the results of a survey among C-suite executives about their state of preparedness in the final countdown to the CECL implementation.

Read More »
Scroll to Top